The anti-abortion foes are doubtless rejoicing (behind closed doors if not in public). The assassination of Dr. George Tiller closed his abortion clinic for good, a goal they were not able to attain by legal means. Not that the same proponents of "Pro Life" hadn't used violence earlier. Dr. Tiller was shot in both arms in 1994, his clinic bombed several times. The Kansas attorney general brought charges against him last year for "failing to properly obtain second medical opinions as required by law" on 19 counts. A local jury acquitted him of all charges. Five other abortion providers have been assassinated in the years since Roe v. Wade was passed. Not a single "Pro Life" proponent has been killed or wounded, or had their organizations attacked.
Pres. Obama has called for dialog and civil discourse on this contentious subject. My take is that this is like calling on the Taliban for reasoned discourse and adherence to the rule of law. The Muslim convert who killed a military recruiter in Little Rock, Arkansas, felt justified by the actions of the U.S. in the Middle East. What you have here are religious extremists, and those on the outer fringe of the debate that take their cues from their less violence inclined proponents. The rhetoric of the conservative right has prevailed in all cases shaping the abortion debate to date. It's "baby murder" pure and simple, likely to call down the wrath of God. Framed in those terms there is no room for rational discussion.
I was for many years deeply opposed to abortion, especially when I belonged to more conservative religious groups. Like most people I still have strong reservations, based primarily on the moral implications. However, I've come to believe that this is a decision made at a personal level. Each one of us is responsible for the decisions we make, and none but God knows the cost and consequences. That's not for us to judge. A woman has a right to control her body, not the body politic to hold her hostage to their beliefs. If we care so deeply for babies let us vote a tax increase to provide appropriate medical care for those children, and their families. Get involved in the local public schools and vote to fund them appropriately. Get involved in dysfunctional communities where children grow up without role models or hope. The list goes on and on. The cheap shot, literally, is to decry the choice to abort the fetus but to ignore the very real needs of the children and families here right now. Decrying abortion is the easy way out that allows the Pro Life-er to avoid the hard choices of real people in real time. On this issue the abstract trumps the concrete.
Gillian has worked at anabortion clinic for a year. It has changed her in many ways, most profoundly by creating in her a deep empathy and compassion for the lives of her patients. She gives parenting resources to anyone who is unsure of this choice, she urges them to think carefully. She holds hands, lifts hearts, works hard for a measly $12 an hour and realizes that there are as many stories and reasons as there are people. Compassion is the quality missing from this debate on both sides. I think we could all benefit from a bit of humility and compassion on this and other issues. And tell that to all the violent extremists around the world.